What game should I play next (Mac)?

Ok, let me first say that I am a *very* casual player of games (which is why I am restricted to just games that can be played on a Mac).

I have really enjoyed playing BioShock and BioShock Infinite, Pillars of Eternity, Minecraft, and World of Warcraft and I am looking for a new game.

Any suggestions? I like story and character driven games as well as RPGs (though I will admit that I'm not as good at RPGs as I would like). I'd prefer a game with an option for playing a female character though I don't mind playing a guy.

Thanks!

Read more: What game should I play next (Mac)?